research(backtest): breakeven-stop exit test, rejected

Pre-registered test of raising the stop to entry once a trade is +1R or
+2R, on top of the 3x ATR trail. be_1r fails the frozen rule (train worse
on all three graded metrics, test drawdown worse); be_2r changes 2 of 480
trades because the trail already reaches entry near +2R. The production
exit stays.

Breakeven exits get their own breakeven_stop label. They follow live
re-entry semantics (only initial-stop exits lock re-entry), and an
ungraded be_1r_gated diagnostic arm sends them through the post-stop gate
reset instead. The trail and breakeven ratchet share one helper, so
breakeven also applies on a next_open fill bar. breakeven_r is validated,
verdicts flag passes that are only ties, and the graded capacity comes
from the shadow book config. Every graded number and the parity row are
unchanged from the first run.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

docs/research/README.md

@@ -48,6 +48,7 @@ score, Structural S/R, the Gate Target Ladder, sentiment, fundamentals) is
 | 11 | **FIP path-smoothness** as tie-breaker/filter | Non-monotonic within the qualified set; thinning the entry stream costs more compounding than the tilt returns | **Rejected as a filter** — but see §4, it's the strongest raw signal we've measured | — |
 | 12 | **Fixed take-profit sweep** (R-multiples) | No interior optimum ever found — the best TP is "no TP" | **Rejected.** Momentum's edge lives in the right tail | `backtest_service.py:450` |
 | 13 | **Sector-residual 12-1** (`mom_12_1_sector_resid` / sector demean) as replacement for market residual | Short-window IC/A/B looked knife-edge green; deep repaired + **liquid-1500** retest: weeks 83, mild +IC **0.027** / t 1.69, **below iron bar 0.03** (FAIL). Demean already weaker | **Rejected / closed.** Keep production market residual. Do not resurrect without a new pre-registered protocol | [sector-residual-momentum.md](sector-residual-momentum.md) · `sector-resid-deep-20260719-113319.json` · history-depth supersession note |
+| 15 | **Breakeven stop** (stop to entry once the trade is +1R / +2R, on top of the 3× ATR trail) | `be_1r` fails the frozen rule: train worse on Sharpe, CAGR and drawdown, test better on return but worse on drawdown. `be_2r` changed 2 of 480 trades, because the trail already reaches entry near +2R. A post-hoc arm that gates re-entry after breakeven exits does better but still fails on drawdown | **Rejected / closed for this snapshot.** Keep the production exit. Reopen only with a new pre-registered test on unseen data | [breakeven-stop.md](breakeven-stop.md) · `backtest-20261009-breakeven-stop.json` |
 
 ---